We have 284,000 km of gas pipeline [1] that will become redundant when (if ever) we have weaned ourselves off gas for heating to reduce GHG emissions. What else can we do with this infrastructure?
I started thinking about this from reading an article from the UKERC about repurposing the gas grid for electricity storage using compressed air [2]. You use electrical power to compress the air and then you get electrical power out by letting the air expand through a turbine (as in a power station, except there the expansion is caused by heat generated from burning the gas). There will be some losses because neither process is 100% efficient. Efficiency may be comparable to high pressure storage in salt caverns which is typically 42% to 55% [5].
Efficiency can be improved (up to 70% for salt caverns) by saving heat generated during compression and reusing it during expansion. However, this is difficult if compression occurs at one end of the pipe and expansion is some distance away.
A quick internet search query found these alternative options for re-using the gas pipes:
Transport other gases.
- Hydrogen
- This assumes demand for hydrogen
- However we are unlikely to use hydrogen as a replacement for methane for domestic heating.
- It is too expensive to make in a low-carbon way
- Making hydrogen and then burning it for heat is less efficient than a heat pump
- Nesta view https://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/opinion-why-hydrogen-is-not-the-solution-to-decarbonising-our-homes/
- Hydrogen is more likely to leak than methane
- This is serious because hydrogen is an indirect greenhouse gas
- CO2
- There is little demand for CO2 in industry, but there is potential value in sequestering it permanently avoiding the greenhouse gas heating impacts. This requires policy support for carbon pricing, to provide a value for avoided emissions.
- The gas pipes could be used for transporting CO2 from where it is generated to another site for sequestration.
- Small scale Industrial uses include:
- Making urea based fertilisers
- Enhanced oil recovery (to extract the last dregs from an oil field)
- Making fizzy drinks
- Pumping beverages through pipework (e.g. for top pressure lagers in pubs)
- Boosting plant growth in greenhouses
- As a fire suppressor
- Biomethane
- Since biomethane is largely methane, the same as natural gas, it makes sense to use the same pipes for transporting it.
- Biomethane is typically produced using anaerobic digestion (AD) of waste organic material.
- The food waste we (in Cambridge) put in our new food caddies will be processed by AD plants in Baldock, March or Thetford and the methane gas used to produce electricity [4]. Although this will supply only a small fraction of our household electricity usage [A.1], it reduces global warming by avoiding methane entering the atmosphere. This is important as methane is a powerful greenhouse gas.
- If food waste is buried in landfill, then the food breaks down slowly and generates methane which must be collected to avoid global warming impacts. This is expensive. Hence food waste should not go to landfill.
Other potential uses for the gas pipe network
- as conduits for fibre-optic cables or other cables
- District heating (ambient loop)
- Decommission and repurpose the land
- o Land that has gas pipes under it could potentially have greater value without the gas pipes as access is required to maintain the pipework. Also there may be restrictions on operating heavy machinery above gas pipes, especially pipes operating at high pressure. Restrictions could also apply to building construction or agricultural operations such as deep cultivation, depending on the depth of the pipes. It is possible to construct buildings over pipelines, with appropriate permission.
District heating
For district heating, the pipework would need to transfer hot (or warm) water instead of natural gas. The existing gas pipes are mostly made of polyethylene and uninsulated. This means they cannot transport hot water. In any case, heat in hot water would quickly be lost to the ground unless the pipework was insulated which would be a massive job. An ambient loop system (close to ground temperature) would minimise heat losses but requires each home to have a heat pump to increase the temperature.
Critically, district heating requires a return loop so that the same water can be reheated and used again - whereas the gas distribution system is essentially one way as the gas is consumed in our boilers.
Not re-using the water used as an energy carrier would mean the water used to carry the heat to our homes would then have to be disposed of another way and more water obtained to carry the next lot of heat. By my rough calculations, our per person water consumption would increase by a factor of 70% or so [A.2] (and even more in winter when heat demand is high). After use all this water would have to go somewhere – probably into the sewers. In any case this volume of water would be very difficult to source where water is already scarce.
It is a nice idea but it seems rather impractical to me, mainly because of the pressure required in pipes made of plastic and the big increase in water use due to the lack of return loop.
Energy storage using compressed air [2]
Energy can be stored in the pipe by using electricity to compress air in the pipes and then generating electricity by allowing it to expand through a turbine. Some of the existing pipework already supports high pressure for storing methane and could be used to store air at 40-80 bar (1 bar = 1 atmosphere.)
As already mentioned, round trip efficiency is unlikely to exceed 60%. This is poor compared to battery storage or pumped storage in high altitude reservoirs. However batteries are expensive and pumped storage is only possible with suitable geography.
The existing high pressure gas pipework is mostly made of high carbon steel and can corrode if there is moisture and oxygen present. Air contains oxygen and water vapour so it would need to be dried before use.
As with any generation asset, the generated electricity needs a connection to the grid whereas pipes for gas mainly rely on pressure gradients for gas transport and would not be connected. Hence new electricity transmission infrastructure may be needed to take the generated power.
Although the pipework is built for high pressures, it is not built for cycles of high and low pressure caused by repeated compression and release through a turbine. These cycles could cause fatigue cracks in the steel which would shorten the usable lifetime of the pipework.
Conclusions
Neither energy storage nor district heating options seem practical so the most likely uses for the redundant gas network remain:
- As channels for cabling e.g. fibre optics for communications
- To carry CO2 gas from industrial sources to locations for sequestration
- Where topology is appropriate and there is government policy to provide value for sequestration
- To carry biomethane from AD plants to power plants for electricity generation
- Where topology is appropriate
All of these uses rely on pipework existing for particular routes but the required routes are hard to predict. This means it is probably sensible to leave the conduits in the ground for use when a requirement transpires. Regardless of final usage, the existing pipework would need to be purged of flammable gas first, for safety.
Appendix – Calculations
A.1 Energy from AD of food waste
- 1kg food waste produces up to 0.26 m3 biogas [3] of which 45-75% is methane
- Pure methane has energy 10 kWh/m3
- CCGT gas power stations in the UK are typically 50% efficient
Hence
- 1kg food waste has an energy content of 1.1 to 2.0 kWh (= m3 gas x % methane x kWh/m3)
- This could produce 0.6 to 1.2 kWh electricity
- This could be supplied by 6 to 12 kg food waste per day
- 29 million households in the UK [7]
- hence 5e6/365/29e6 tonnes/day/household
- = 0.5 kg/household/day
The collected food waste (0.5 kg/day) is a small fraction of that required to generate electricity for a household ( 6 to 12 kg/day).
A.2 How much water is needed to carry heat to a typical home
- Annual heating gas consumption 12000 kWh gas/year/home
- 14 kWh/day/person
- 11 kWh/day/person useful heat (assuming boiler efficiency 80%)
- Assume district heating water drops in temperature by 7°C so
- Water required to carry heat is 105 litres/person/day
A.3 Comparing the volume of gas used with the volume of water to carry the same heat energy
- Volumetric energy density for natural gas 38 MJ/m3
- The gas mains runs at close to atmospheric pressure.
- Allow for gas boiler efficiency 80% means useful heat is perhaps 30 MJ/m3
- In our homes, we extract heat from the water – say delta T is 7°C (using an ambient loop means we only have a low delta T).
- Specific heat capacity for water is 4.2 J/g/K. so for 1m3 pipe volume (1e6 g) the heat stored is close to 30 MJ/m3
- = 7 x 4.2*1e6 J/m3
- = 29*1e6 J/m3
- = 29 MJ/m3
So reusing gas mains for district heating the flow rate would need to be similar to that of the natural gas, even though the viscosity of water is much greater – approximately 100 times that of natural gas. This would mean that the pressure used in the pipe would have to be 100 times greater.
References
[1] https://www.nesta.org.uk/feature/future-signals-2024/shutting-down-the-gas-grid/
[3] How Much Biogas Does 1 kg of Food Waste Produce? Understanding Kitchen Waste-to-Energy Conversion
https://www.sjz-zztc.com/how-much-biogas-does-1-kg-of-food-waste-produce/
‘On average, food waste can generate approximately 90 to 260 litres of biogas per kilogram, with methane content typically ranging from 50% to 74% .'
[4] Thousands more homes to receive weekly food waste collections (Cambridge City Council) (Oct 2026)
https://www.cambridge.gov.uk/news/2026/10/08/thousands-more-homes-to-receive-weekly-food-waste-collections
[5] Development status and prospect of salt cavern energy storage technology (2025)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2950154725000017#tbl0020
[6] An introduction to biogas and biomethane (IEA)
‘The methane content of biogas typically ranges from 45% to 75% by volume’
[7] Families and households in the UK: 2025 (ONS)
· 29 million households in the UK
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments on this blog are moderated. Your comment will not appear until it has been reviewed.